Omni-Man vs Superman [7 Reasons] Why Fans Are Obsessed

Robert Kirkman discusses Omni-Man defeating Superman during New York Comic-Con interview

Robert Kirkman Reignites Omni-Man vs Superman Debate at NYCC

Introduction

At New York Comic-Con (NYCC) 2025, Invincible creator Robert Kirkman set social media ablaze by claiming that Omni-Man would easily defeat Superman. As superhero media surges with hits like James Gunn’s Superman and the upcoming third season of Invincible on Prime Video, Kirkman’s bold statements have reignited one of the most popular “who would win?” debates among fans.

Kirkman's Bold Statement at NYCC

During an interview with Collider's Maggie Lovitt, Kirkman did not hold back:

"Well, Homelander is a weakling... But Superman sucks. Omni-Man takes him down easily... Every time I say it, a bunch of Superman fans... attack me online... Omni-Man would completely trash that guy."

Kirkman referenced Superman’s classic feats, including moving planets, while teasing potential increases in Omni-Man's powers in future Invincible seasons.

Context Behind the Debate

This is not the first time Kirkman weighed in. In 2024, similar comments sparked online debates, memes, and fan arguments. The timing coincides with renewed interest in superhero crossovers:

  • Gunn's Superman movie revitalizes DC's universe.
  • Invincible Season 3 premieres February 2026, with Season 4 following in March 2026.
  • Storylines in upcoming seasons promise epic battles against Thragg and new villains.

Omni-Man’s portrayal as a ruthless Viltrumite conqueror contrasts with Kirkman’s view of Superman as overrated, despite the Man of Steel's cultural significance.

Social Media Reactions

Fans erupted on X (formerly Twitter) after @TheCartoonBase shared Kirkman's comments. Responses were divided:

  • Supporters agreed with Kirkman’s opinion, emphasizing Omni-Man’s brutality.
  • Superman fans highlighted feats like multiverse-level strength.
  • Humorous memes, fan art, and references to other pop culture battles flooded the thread.

The debate illustrates the enthusiasm and passion of superhero communities online.

Why This Debate Captivates Fans

  1. Speculative Fun: Hypothetical battles let fans imagine impossible matchups.
  2. Creator Involvement: Kirkman directly engaging fans fuels excitement.
  3. Cross-Media Appeal: Both Invincible and Superman are culturally iconic.
  4. Social Media Virality: Memes and posts amplify discussions globally.
  5. Upcoming Storylines: New seasons provide in-universe context for power scaling.
  6. Community Engagement: Fans feel part of ongoing debates.
  7. Pop Culture Influence: Matches blend comic book history with modern storytelling.

FAQs

Q1: Is Omni-Man actually stronger than Superman?

A: It’s subjective. Kirkman claims yes, based on Invincible’s portrayal, but DC fans point to Superman's planet-moving feats.

Q2: When is Invincible Season 3 coming out?

A: February 2026, with Season 4 expected in March 2026.

Q3: Who voiced Thragg in Invincible?

A: Lee Pace returns as the formidable Viltrumite antagonist.

Q4: Does this debate affect canon Superman comics or movies?

A: No. This is speculative and meant for fan engagement and discussion.

Q5: Where can I watch the latest Invincible episodes?

A: On Amazon Prime Video.

Neutral Conclusion

While Kirkman’s claim that Omni-Man would "trash" Superman sparks excitement and humor online, the debate is ultimately speculative. Both characters have unique narratives, powers, and cultural significance. Omni-Man represents a brutal, morally complex Viltrumite, while Superman embodies decades of heroic ideals and feats across multiverses. Fans on both sides are justified in their opinions, and this discussion underscores the enduring appeal of superhero matchups. What’s certain is that Invincible and DC’s characters will continue to inspire debates, fan art, and cross-universe “what if” scenarios for years to come.

0 comments

Leave a comment